Significant Sale: Historic Property at 72 Main Street

A landmark moment in Nantucket Island’s real estate market has been reached, as the historic property at 72 Main Street has found a new owner.

When it comes to showcasing the rich history and architectural brilliance of Nantucket Island, few properties are as captivating as 72 Main Street. This stately Greek Revival home stands as an enduring symbol of the island’s past, offering a glimpse into a bygone era where artistry and grandeur dominated the landscape. With its meticulously preserved exterior and carefully modernized interior, 72 Main Street exemplifies how historic properties can merge the past with the present while maintaining their original charm.

This six-bedroom, six-and-a-half-bath home spans an impressive 6,804 square feet of living space. Every detail of this architectural masterpiece has been thoughtfully maintained, from its neo-classical features to the effortless integration of modern conveniences.

This standout sale was achieved by none other than Bernadette Meyer. Known for her extensive understanding of the island's prestigious properties and relentless dedication to her clients, Bernadette has successfully brokered the sale of this extraordinary home.

With its rich history and ever-impressive architecture, this sale represents a major achievement in Nantucket’s real estate landscape.

Built over two centuries ago, 72 Main Street has long stood as a beacon of refined taste. The home’s Greek Revival architecture immediately commands attention with its symmetrical façade, iconic columns, and elegantly preserved exterior.

As you approach the property, the grand portico greets you, complete with intricately designed balustrades, setting the stage for the artistry that lies within. The front entrance, adorned with a stunning transom and sidelights featuring leaded glass panes, floods the foyer with natural light, creating an inviting and luminous space. The foyer sets the tone for what lies beyond, with its gracious proportions and a sense of quiet sophistication.

The east parlor invites you in with its original black marble fireplace and intricate plasterwork, mirrored in the west parlor, creating a harmonious symmetry that defines the Greek Revival style. Toward the rear, the open-concept gathering area flows effortlessly into a state-of-the-art chef's kitchen — a perfect unity of contemporary design and historic charm. A third parlor, complete with pocket doors and yet another elegant marble fireplace, offers both intimacy and functionality.

Ascending the grand staircase, the second floor reveals four ensuite bedrooms, each a sanctuary of comfort and style. The original detailing is evident in each room, with modern conveniences carefully integrated to enhance the living experience. The primary suite, the crown jewel of the second floor, features a spacious walk-in closet and a lavish bathroom that is a work of art in itself with marble surfaces, double vanities, and premium fixtures.

On the third floor, natural light floods the space from the grand cupola, accentuating the exposed beams and artistic sensibilities. An expansive private bedroom and an office with stunning views of the town and harbor create a tranquil retreat.

The finished lower level, designed for entertainment and leisure, offers a fitness space and garden-accessible guest suite. Outdoors, the timeless beauty of the home is echoed in the pristinely manicured grounds, where moments of relaxation and lively al fresco dinners await amid a serene backdrop of mature trees and carefully curated landscaping.

This wasn’t just a transaction — it was a carefully executed strategy that honored the home’s storied past while ensuring its place in the future.

At the heart of this sale was the home itself: a masterpiece of Nantucket’s architectural splendor. From the moment we stepped through its grand entrance, it was clear that this was no ordinary property. 72 Main Street isn’t just a house; it’s a story told through centuries of design, elegance, and prestige. Every inch of this Greek Revival gem reflects the island’s golden era, making it a truly iconic property that commanded attention from the start.

To truly capture the essence of this incredible home, we had to go beyond the surface. That’s why we worked closely with Mary Bergman, Executive Director of the Nantucket Preservation Trust, to gain a thorough understanding of the property’s place in Nantucket’s history. This wasn’t just about selling a home. Rather, it was about passing on a piece of history, and that emotional connection became a powerful driver in the transaction.

Preserving history while enhancing modern appeal requires vast skill, focused precision, and an unwavering respect for the past. Enter The Castle Group, Nantucket’s leading experts in historic home renovations. Their work on 72 Main Street was nothing short of phenomenal. They brought the property into the 21st century without sacrificing a single detail of its original charm.

From restoring intricate architectural features to integrating discrete modern conveniences, The Castle Group ensured that the home would stand as both a historical artifact and a functional modern residence. The result? A seamless fusion of past and present.

A property of this caliber deserved to be showcased on the world stage, and that’s exactly what we did. Leveraging the unparalleled global reach of Sotheby's International Realty, we ensured 72 Main Street caught the eye of discerning buyers around the globe. Our collaboration with key colleagues like Stan Ponte in NYC and Joe Barbieri with Sotheby's International Realty | Greenwich, CT, opened doors. Through this strategic network, we connected with individuals who appreciate not just luxury but the legacy of owning a truly unique property.

We knew this home’s story had to be told far and wide. That’s why we partnered with Sotheby’s PR team for top-tier media coverage in The Wall Street Journal and other top outlets. These features amplified the outreach of our marketing efforts, positioning 72 Main Street as a property of national and international importance.

In a sale like this, visuals are everything. We needed to capture the essence of 72 Main Street in a way that would stop buyers in their tracks. Enter Jack Vatcher, an extraordinary photographer based in Boston whose incredible photography and video brought the home’s grandeur to life. Every image and every frame conveyed the timeless elegance and architectural intrigue of this property.

Finally, the key to sealing the deal was our deep-rooted relationships within the Nantucket Brokerage Community. This wasn’t just about casting a wide net. It was about making the right connections to drive interest and build momentum from the ground up. With support and collaboration, we were able to attract buyers who understood the rarity and value of this historic home.

In the end, this sale was far more than just a successful transaction. It was a celebration of Nantucket’s rich history and a reminder that some properties transcend time. 72 Main Street will continue to stand as a symbol of the past while welcoming its next chapter.

Whether you are drawn to its architectural beauty, its historical significance, or its modern conveniences, properties like these are a true gem in the heart of Nantucket. Check out the property details, and team up with expert broker Bernadette Meyer to explore the Nantucket Island real estate scene.

_{*Header photo courtesy of Bernadette Meyer}